Could Russia Accept NATO-Like Security Guarantees for Ukraine?
In 24 hours, the world heard two very different versions of the same story. In Berlin, a U.S. envoy said Russia was on board. A day later, a Russian official said that was not the case.
What Was Said in Berlin
U.S. negotiator Jared Kushner told reporters on Thursday that he and fellow envoy Steve Witkoff had made the Russians “comfortable” with the idea that any security guarantee for Ukraine would be based on Article 5.
Article 5 is NATO’s core promise: an attack on one member is an attack on all. For Kyiv, such guarantees should be legally binding, approved by Congress and mirror Article 5.
Moscow Pushes Back
The reply came fast. On Friday, Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said even a “creative” formula for Ukraine’s quasi-membership in NATO is unacceptable to Moscow.
His condition was blunt. Ukraine must first accept that it will never join NATO, and only then can security guarantees be discussed. Russia, he said, views the issue mainly as a matter of its own security.
Why the Mixed Signals?
The two statements may not be as contradictory as they sound. Nobody has yet defined what “Article 5-like” would mean in practice. European and Ukrainian officials privately admit they haven’t fully resolved it.
Analysts see one risk clearly. If Moscow decides these guarantees are real, it may reject the deal and send negotiations back to square one. Russia has also said it will not accept NATO troops on Ukrainian soil.
Why It Matters to Ordinary People
For Ukrainians, this is the difference between a ceasefire that holds and one that collapses. Kyiv has said it is ready to drop its NATO bid in exchange for stronger Western guarantees.
For Europeans, it raises questions about military commitments and costs. For Russians, it decides whether the war drags on.
The fighting hasn’t paused for diplomacy. Russian strikes on Kyiv’s bridges killed eight people across Ukraine on Friday, while the war nears its fifth anniversary.
Explore the Latest Developments Shaping Global Security, Diplomacy, and the Russia-Ukraine War
Why Is Japan Concerned About Russian Aircraft?
How Is the UAE Shaping Ukraine Peace Efforts?
Can Prisoner Swaps Bring Ukraine Peace Closer?
What Could Abu Dhabi Peace Talks Change?
Could Russian Gas Flow Into Europe Again?
